• Home
  • Words
    • Passages of Love
    • New Works
  • Images
    • Light & Dark
    • fittxu u ssibu
    • Machina
    • Money Can’t Buy Me Love
    • The Pixel
    • la vue exempte de désirs
    • The Isle of the Dead
    • by a madman
    • jalousie [21:52]
    • Alcaide
    • Senduq
  • Dirty Paradise
  • Blog
  • MA Photography
  • About me
  • Contact
Start typing and press
Enter to search
  • Vimeo
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
Follow
Skip to content

Marco Montalto

poetry | photography | philosophy

open search form close search form
  • Home
  • Words
    • Passages of Love
    • New Works
  • Images
    • Light & Dark
    • fittxu u ssibu
    • Machina
    • Money Can’t Buy Me Love
    • The Pixel
    • la vue exempte de désirs
    • The Isle of the Dead
    • by a madman
    • jalousie [21:52]
    • Alcaide
    • Senduq
  • Dirty Paradise
  • Blog
  • MA Photography
  • About me
  • Contact
By: montaltomarco April 6, 2020January 2, 2021
Bloganalogue photography, apparatuses, automatic mode, automatism, binary code, copy, creation, digital photography, Franz Kafka, Hercalitus, images, improbable, informative, language, metadata, negative, non-informative, ontology, original, ownership, parable, philosophy of photography, photography, Photoshop, presets, probable, program, programmer, raw file, redundant, smartphone, the photographic project, unique, updates, Vilém Flusser, virtualities

On Parables

Heraclitus is said to have said that “you cannot step into the same river twice” (PLATO 1997: 120). For brevity’s sake, let us assume that that statement that is said to have been said by Heraclitus is sensical and refers to a verifiable perceptual phenomenon that when experienced makes everything come to be perceived as being in constant change. Assuming all that, we come to see that a photograph is always an original; that there cannot be two photographs which are copies of each other (unless printed from the same negative – but that’s not what we are concerned with here); that multiple photographs taken of the same subject in quick succession are essentially non-alike and that each one of those photographs ought to be treated as unique.

Taking stock of all that has just been argued, we can easily see how the photographic project has failed. In the process of giving everyone the ability to easily produce images, photography has gone off on a tangent, giving birth to an automatism substantially, significantly and ontologically different to its inherent ontologically-determined automatism, understood as the automatism that is at play in the production of an image that is reliant simply on the pressing of the shutter-release button. The automatism we are making reference to here is the automatism known as the ‘automatic mode’; the automatism inherent in taking photographs using a smartphone, where we’re told that “each photo and video…is the original […] – without filters, adjustments or retouching” (AFAQS! 2016) (…and surely, with all photographs coming out looking the same, we have come to see the world through that filter of sameness; and if our photographs come out looking like the world we have come to see through that filter of sameness, then they surely must be original – “well, they surely haven’t been tinkered with – they look just the same as everybody else’s!”); the automatism in the workflow of the professional photographer on manual mode using Photoshop presets… (I believe I have covered all the scenarios.)

Flusser says: “reduced to its basic elements, the camera’s program is as follows: first, to place its inherent capabilities into the image; second, to make use of a photographer for this purpose, except in borderline cases of total automation (for example, in the case of satellite photographs); third, to distribute the images produced in this way so that society is in a feedback relationship to the camera which makes it possible for the camera to improve progressively; fourth, to produce better and better images. In short: The camera’s program provides for the realization of its capabilities and, in the process, for the use of society as a feedback mechanism for its progressive improvement” (2000: 46). The camera’s program is thus continuously updated to incorporate within it the latest fads and trends – essentially novel, hitherto unexplored ways of using the camera, approbated by society, and later programmed by the programmer and fashioned as new updates to the photography apparatus.

Photographers operating in any one of the three scenarios delineated previously are not only taking a false sense of ownership over ‘their’ images (clearly, these images are not ‘theirs’; these images are simply programmed virtualities being emitted by the photography apparatus); their malpractice calls into question the very status of these images as photographs, since photographs have here been argued to be always original, unique and non-alike. As Flusser argues, operating strictly within those parts of the camera’s program that are already well explored produces “redundant, non-informative images, similar to those one has seen before” (2000: 36-37).

Now, the solution to this malpractice may seem obvious to some: photographers should never stop experimenting with the photography apparatus and should consistently produce “informative, improbable images that have not been seen before” (FLUSSER 2000: 37). But, Flusser himself warns: “a number of human beings are struggling against this automatic programming: photographers who attempt to produce informative images, i.e. photographs that are not part of the program of apparatus; critics who attempt to see what is going on in the automatic game of programming; and in general, all those who are attempting to create a space for human intention in a world dominated by apparatuses. However, the apparatuses themselves automatically assimilate these attempts at liberation and enrich their programs with them. It is consequently the task of a philosophy of photography to expose this struggle between human being and apparatuses in the field of photography and to reflect on a possible solution to the conflict” (Ibid. 74-75).

Let us return to our introductory argument in which we claimed that a photograph is always an original and unique, and that no two photographs are ever alike. Clearly, we can see that this argument holds true for analogue photography but doesn’t fare so well with digital photography. The silver halide crystals present on photographic film react to form silver metal when exposed to light. This chemical reaction produces a dark image on the film. In analogue photography, thus, the relationship between the image and its determinant is non-arbitrary. In digital photography, the negative, so to speak, is the raw image file, which is a digital file that can be copied infinite times (unlike the ‘true’ negative in analogue photography, which is a unique object). In digital photography, the relationship between the digital image and its determinant (essentially a digital file containing a series of 1s and 0s – binary code) is completely arbitrary, wholly dependent on the whim of the programmer of the intelligent (or interpreting) machine.  

Now we enter the usual conundrum: in the digital domain, a digital raw image file is considered as being original, analogous to the negative in analogue photography. With the possibility of the digital raw image file being digitally copied always lurking in the shadows, and with such eventual copies being eventually identical to this original raw image file, the original raw image file cannot be considered original anymore, and the resultant copies cannot be categorised as copies either. Clearly, had all these identical digital raw image files to be considered as being all originals, that would defeat from now onwards the purpose of ever calling something again original… and should they be considered all copies – copies without an original? Can that even be conceived?

Clearly, we can access the metadata embedded in the raw image file and see who the original creator of the image was (unless that happens to have been tinkered with and we end up with some fictitious Henriette Cartier-Bresson). 

Let us return to Flusser’s argument on the camera program and see whether we can reach some conclusion. Dear Vilém, the hitherto unexplored parts of the camera program must always exceed the hitherto explored limits of the camera program, otherwise that wouldn’t be a very good photography camera that we bought, right? The “struggle between human being and apparatuses” (FLUSSER 2000: 75) is resolved by human being claiming its own creation (creation being for all apparatuses a delicate argument ‘they’ prefer to avoid). 

That great ignoramus, Franz Kafka, managed to write one genial piece of literature, a parable he aptly titled, ‘On Parables’, and here it goes:

“Many complain that the words of the wise are always merely parables and of no use in daily life, which is the only life we have. When the sage says: “Go over,” he does not mean that we should cross over to some actual place, which we could do anyhow if the labor were worth it; he means some fabulous yonder, something unknown to us, something too that he cannot designate more precisely either, and therefore cannot help us here in the very least. All these parables really set out to say merely that the incomprehensible is incomprehensible, and we know that already. But the cares we have to struggle with every day: that is a different matter.

Concerning this a man once said: Why such reluctance? If you only followed the parables you yourselves would become parables and with that rid of all your daily cares.

Another said: I bet that is also a parable.

The first said: You have won.

The second said: But unfortunately only in parable.

The first said: No, in reality: in parable you have lost.” (KAFKA 1999: 457)

Do not be disheartened by this post! I will clearly manage to write other beautiful posts about other interesting topics about the wonderful art of photography, even if that essentially means writing further posts containing much of the same arguments… So fuck jazz, too.

P.S. Language too is fiction and we are as a matter of fact as mute as animals. 

References:

AFAQS!. 2016. ‘Apple Stuns Once Again; Displays Ads Clicked On iPhone 6s, 6s Plus’. afaqs! [online]. Available at: https://www.afaqs.com/news/story/47055_Apple-Stuns-Once-Again-Displays-Ads-Clicked-On-iPhone-6s-6s-Plus [accessed 6 April 2020].

FLUSSER, Vilém. 2000. Towards a Philosophy of Photography. London: Reaktion Books.

KAFKA, Franz. 1999. The Complete Short Stories of Franz Kafka. UK: Vintage.

PLATO. 1997. Complete Works. USA: Hackett Publishing Company.

Featured Image:

Pixel Peeps. March 2020 at Sliema, Malta. Digital illustration by the author.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
  • Email
Bloganalogue photography, apparatuses, automatic mode, automatism, binary code, copy, creation, digital photography, Franz Kafka, Hercalitus, images, improbable, informative, language, metadata, negative, non-informative, ontology, original, ownership, parable, philosophy of photography, photography, Photoshop, presets, probable, program, programmer, raw file, redundant, smartphone, the photographic project, unique, updates, Vilém Flusser, virtualities
Posted by:montaltomarco

Post navigation

On pain and how to photograph it
Curating the Archive

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

montaltomarco

montaltomarco
À Dieu, Dasein New blog post published on my per À Dieu, Dasein

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/04/27/a-dieu-dasein/

#philosophyofphotography #photography #contemporaryphotography #philosophy #ontology #dasein
Punish me with kisses New blog post published on Punish me with kisses

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/04/21/punish-me-with-kisses/

#philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #goldenmole #karlpopper
Tereża New blog post published on my personal we Tereża

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/04/14/tereza/

#philosophyofphotography #photography #contemporaryphotography #philosophy #thephotographic
Axel’s Island New blog post published on my per Axel’s Island

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/04/02/axels-island/

#philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #julesverne
The White Rabbit (Part 3 of 3) New blog post publ The White Rabbit (Part 3 of 3)

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/03/22/the-white-rabbit-part-3-of-3/

#philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #thephotographic #alterity #theother
The White Rabbit (Part 2 of 3) New blog post publ The White Rabbit (Part 2 of 3)

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/03/15/the-white-rabbit-part-2-of-3/

#philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #light #theatre
The White Rabbit (Part 1 of 3) New blog post publ The White Rabbit (Part 1 of 3)

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/03/08/the-white-rabbit-part-1-of-3/

#philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #analoguephotography #digitalphotography #pixel #statistics
Happy St. Valentine’s ❤️ To celebrate, a n Happy St. Valentine’s ❤️ 

To celebrate, a new blog post:

The Eyes are the Moons

Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/02/14/the-eyes-are-the-moons/

Also, recently published a new poem with the same title under Words>New Works (scroll down to see the latest works). 

#philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #staugustine
The Eyes are the Moons New poem just published on The Eyes are the Moons

New poem just published on my website under Words>New Works (scroll down to see the latest works). Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/new-works/
Happy 3rd anniversary to my personal website! To c Happy 3rd anniversary to my personal website! To celebrate, a little treat:

I(:) met you

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2022/01/27/i-met-you/

#photography #contemporaryphotography #philosophyofphotography #philosophy #emmanuellevinas #happybirthday
The Investiture of that Name Last blog post for t The Investiture of that Name

Last blog post for the year just published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2021/12/24/the-investiture-of-that-name/

Happy Christmas to all 🎄 

#photography #contemporaryphotography #philosophyofphotography #philosophy #husserl
Ave Sol New poem just published on my personal we Ave Sol

New poem just published on my personal website under Words>New Works. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/new-works/
Speciously Valid New blog post published on my pe Speciously Valid

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2021/12/03/speciously-valid/

#wittgensteinscolor #photography #philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #philosophy
𝑦=25+2𝑥 New blog post published on my perso 𝑦=25+2𝑥

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2021/11/08/y252x/

#memory #perception #samuelbeckett #kyla #kelma
by a madman Another one added to the gallery. Che by a madman

Another one added to the gallery. Check it out! Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/by-a-madman/

#edvardmunch #vangogh
by a madman New image added to this gallery. Lin by a madman 

New image added to this gallery. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/by-a-madman/

#edvardmunch #22nov21
See you New blog post published on my personal we See you

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2021/10/27/see-you/

#philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #bertrandrussell
No blog posts to share with the world this time. No blog posts to share with the world this time. 

Pictures are mightier than words. 

And only the Other can break a heart. 

Sleep well, Emmanuel xx
Addio, teorema New blog post published on my per Addio, teorema 

New blog post published on my personal website. Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/2021/10/16/addio-teorema/

📸 The exalted gharāniq: Manāt [left], Allāt [middle] and al-‘Uzzā [right] (from personal project Dirty Paradise: in search of a lost photograph). Photographed between March and April 2019 at Paola, Malta, and edited into a triptych October 2021 at Fundão, Portugal. Photographs and edit by the author.

#Rel1=On #philosophyofphotography #contemporaryphotography #photography #philosophy #pasolini
Senduq Unhappy that I am, I cannot heave My hear Senduq 

Unhappy that I am, I cannot heave
My heart into my mouth. I love your Majesty 
According to my bond, no more nor less.

Link in bio or here: https://montaltomarco.com/senduq/
Load More… Follow me on Instagram

Categories

  • Blog
  • MA Photography
    • Positions & Practice
    • Strategies & Surfaces
    • Sustainable Prospects

Tags

#Rel1=On absurd absurdity account acheiropoieta act action active Adam and Eve addition adjective adverb aesthetics agency A Grunt's Life ahistorical alcaide Alec Soth Aletheia Alex Stoddard allegory aloneness alterity amorphous analogue analogue photography Anastasia Samoylova ancient greeks Anton Chekhov anxiety a posteriori apparatus apparatuses appear appearing Apple appropriation arbitrary Ariella Azoulay art artefact artefacted history art gallery artifice artificial artist artistic Asian Elephant association atemporal atom atomic structure audience Auschwitz autarchy author authority authorship automatic automaticity automatic mode automatism awareness bad photograph baroque be beautiful beauty beginning being being-as-such beings belief beloved Bernd and Hilla Becher Bertrand Russell binary code biology Bioparco di Roma bitmap Blake Stimson blind body brain brief broken Bruna Ginammi bureaucracy caged birds canonical care carpe diem Cartesian doubt cataphatic causal causality causation challenge chance necessity change Charles Sanders Peirce childhood Chip Litherland choice Christ Christ and Satan Christian Metz christians cities civic Claire Bishop classical principles code cogito cognition cognitive collaboration color colour communication comparison con-artist concealing conceptual concern Confucius connection conscience consciousness constant construct contact container contemporary photography content context contextual contextualise contingency control conventions copied copy corruption cortical homunculus craft cranes created creation criminal criticism cubism cynicism Damon Winter dark darkness Dark Night of the Soul Dasein data datum David Campany day dead city death deception decode deferred demosaicing deoxyribonucleic acid depravity depth Descartes desire desirelessness Dessau destroying destruction detail determinant determined dichotomous dichotomy différance digital digital domain digital photography digits Ding an sich Dino Buzzati disappear discipline disfiguring dissimulate dissimulated dissimulating distance distinctions diurnal divide divided DNA dogmas doing done by hand double doubt drama drawings dreams dualism dynamic dynamics Early American editing Edmund Husserl Ed Ruscha Edward Hopper effort electron microscope elements embodiment Emmanuel Levinas enact encounter end end in itself end of time error eskhaton eternally ethical ethics Eurydice evaluation everything evidence evidential evidentiary exhibition existence exit experience experiencing eye eyes F. H. Jacobi face facilitator facta falling Falmouth Flexible Falmouth University false falsehood false memory falsification principle family albums fatal fate faux pas Federico García Lorca feel fetish fiction figure of speech filched film final major project finite finitude forgetfulness forgetting forgotten form Franz Kafka freedom free will future futurity genealogy Genesis genetic Geoff Dyer geometry George Santayana Gestapo ghosts gift Giorgio Agamben Giovanni Drogo Giuseppe Calì Global Image God gods hands healing hear hearsay heart Heidegger Henri Cartier-Bresson Henri Van Lier Hercalitus heropoiito hieroglyphs Hipstamatic historical historical time historicised history homunculi human human being human body human eye Humberto Maturana hyperrealism I I am icon Idea identical identity ignorance Il deserto dei Tartari illusion illusions illusory image image manipulation imagery images Immanuel Kant improbable index indexed indexical indexicality individualism infinite infinity information informative inquiry in relation to Instagram intensity intention intentional intentionality intentions interpolation interpreter interpreting invention irreal isle iterating iterative itself Jacques Derrida Jacques Rancière Jean Baudrillard Jeff Bark Jeff Mitchell jew Joanna Zylinska Johannes Vermeer John A Walker John Baldessari John Keats Jonathan Franzen Joseph Nicéphore Niépce Jo Spence Juliet Ferguson just in my head Kendall Walton know knowing knowingly knowledge laboratories laboratory Landings Landings2019 language latent law laws learning lens lethe letting go lie life light linear perspective linguistic linguistic act linguistically constituted linguistic expression litter logic looking love lover Luigi Ghirri Lydia Pang macro madness magic make-believe malformation Malta Maltese Man MA Photography maps Marshall McLuhan Masquerade matter Maurice Denis meaning measure medium memories memory mental image mental phenomenon message meta metadata metaphor metaphysical Michelangelo Michel Foucault micro mind mindset mirror misery mnemosyne mode model modelling modern art modern movement morphology motion motoric act movement mute mythology name narrative nazi negative Nigel Farage night nighttime nihilation nil noctuaries non-arbitrary non-being non-fatality non-informative non-modal non-phenomena non-phenomenal non-revealing nonhuman normative nostalgia nothing noun nouns now number object objectification objective knowledge objectivity Omar Khayyám online learning ontico-ontological ontological ontology openness orientation origin original Other otherness others otherwise ownership Pablo Picasso pain paint painter painterly painters painting paintings paper parable parallel parallel dimensions past pattern Paul Delaroche pedagogue pedagogy perceive perception perceptive system performativity performing permanence perturbation Perugino Peter Beard phenomenon philosophers philosophy philosophy of light philosophy of photography photo photobook photograph Photographer photographic photographic exercise photographic project photographic universe photographs photography photography apparatus photojournalism Photoshop Photoshoppers phototherapy physical picture plane Piet Mondrian pilfered pixel plagiarism plagiaristic pluralism pointless poison political positive post-aesthetic post-aesthetic age post-historical post-photography post-processing posterity Poussin poverty pragmatism praxis pre-ontological precision prediction predictive presence present presets primum movens printing probable process program programme programmed programmer progression proposal publication punctum pure purpose quality question questioning Ralph Rugoff Raphaelle Peale raster graphics ratio scale raw file real realism reality reality horror realness reasoning recognising recognition record reductionism redundant refresh rate relation relationality relationship remediation remember remembering remixing renaissance repeat photography rephotography represent representation representations reproduction res cogitans res extensa responsibility retina reveal revealing revelation revelatory Ricard Martínez risk Roland Barthes romanticize Rosy Martin Rubáiyát Saint John of the Cross Salvador Dali scarlet beast schism science scientific investigation scientific method secrets see seeing seen Self self-disclosure self-violation selfhood semantic semantics sense organ sensible sensing sensual sensuous separation Sharon Core shipbuilding cranes shutter-release button sight sighted sightful sighting sign signify silence silent silver halide silver halide crystal simile simulacrum simulation sin singular Sistine Sisyphean site sited siting smartphone smell snapping snapshot social Sofia soul sound space speak speed of light split St. Augustine staged stance statistical modelling Stephanie Galea still life straight photography Stranger straying studium stupid subject subjected subjection subjective subjective knowledge subjectivises subjectivity substance superior surfaces Susan Sontag symbol tacit taste technique technology technē tempus fugit terrain territory text the aesthetic regime of art the anthropocene theatre the cogito The Creation of Adam the Desired the face the fall the filmic the future the knowing the now theory the Other the past the persistence of memory the photographic the photographic project the pictorial the present the real the same the unknown thing thinking Thomas Ruff thoughts threesome time to be to do to know tone tool to see totality to think touch trace traditional transparent travel true true image true memory truth type typologist typology ugly undecipherable undetermined unique unit of speed universe unknowable unknowingly updates vandalism vanity vector graphics Veil of Veronica veracity Vera Icon viewfinder Vilém Flusser Vince Aletti vintage violence virtual virtualities virtuality vision visual arts visual percept vitalist voice volition Véronique Ducharme wandering wavelengths wholeness whore Wildlife Photographer of the Year Wildlife Photography Wilfred Bion will William Anastasi wisdom witnessing Wittgenstein word words work work in progress workshop world WPY wrong end Zeitgeist zero élan
April 2020
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  
« Mar   May »

My current location


Privacy Policy Cookie Policy
error:
This website uses cookies to give you an optimal online experience. By using this website, you agree to this website's use of cookies.  Accept Reject Settings Read More
Manage Consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
This is an necessary category.
Non Necessary
This is an non-necessary category.
Uncategorized
Undefined cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Preferences
Preference cookies are used to store user preferences to provide content that is customized and convenient for the users, like the language of the website or the location of the visitor.
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.